Does the decision
survive the edit?
Judge the work before the method labels. No suggested winner.
Keep: the girl's face and braided hair, red coat, gesture, blink, head turn and hand holding the staff, at the original times. Change: the forest becomes glacial blue, then amber dawn enters the frozen scene. Illumination and shading may change.
Each pair contains two workflows attempting the same brief, with the original source alongside. Labels A/B were assigned before the new video results. The workflows have different access to source information. This review measures your judgment of these examples; it does not establish a fair algorithm benchmark or a skilled-artist comparison. Visual clues may reveal a method.
Look for the hand rising to the mouth and lowering, the blink near the end, and continuous contact with the staff. Do not treat a prettier background as proof that these decisions survived. “Unclear” is a valid answer.
Spring (2019) — © Blender Foundation | cloud.blender.org/spring · CC BY 4.0. Source passage 107.75–110.75 seconds. No audio in this visual-performance comparison.