{
  "status": "not accepted for revision 2",
  "reviewer": "agent visual inspection; not independent artistic review",
  "method": "Full decode of both clips; visual review of eight timestamp-matched source/output pairs at 0.083, 0.750, 1.500, 1.750, 2.500, 3.250, 3.667 and 3.792 seconds, with a full-resolution output end-frame inspection. This is sampled visual review, not exhaustive temporal certification.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "commitment": "environment transformation",
      "result": "visually achieved",
      "evidence": "A conspicuous frozen blue environment replaces the warm desert throughout the inspected samples."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "duration and frame count",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "Both videos fully decode to 92 frames at 24 fps, duration 3.833333 seconds. Output is 1920x1080; uploaded source was 1280x720, upscaled from 640x360."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "broad action sequence",
      "result": "appears retained in sampled pairs",
      "evidence": "Fall, face-down pose, recovery and jump occur at closely corresponding sample times. Exact pose/timing preservation is not certified."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "exact character appearance",
      "result": "does not pass",
      "evidence": "Orange hair is remodeled into a softer, more detailed shape; hair silhouette and character surface/face details differ from the source."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "exact environment layout",
      "result": "does not pass",
      "evidence": "Major cactus and path composition remain recognizable, but rock contours, surface relief and smaller environmental features are reconstructed."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "camera",
      "result": "broad framing appears similar",
      "evidence": "The later camera movement is recognizable in sampled pairs. Native camera parameters cannot be recovered or certified from this output."
    },
    {
      "commitment": "released backpack and small details",
      "result": "unresolved",
      "evidence": "No full object tracking or frame-by-frame prop inspection has been completed."
    }
  ],
  "decision": "Retain the raw edit as a useful direct-model baseline. Do not treat it as exact preservation or automatically feed it to the amber-dawn revision.",
  "further_generation": "None submitted or authorized.",
  "claim_boundary": "One development shot and one sample. This demonstrates Runway integration and a visible transformation, not an Afterimage advantage, an independent benchmark, or a novel control capability."
}