{
  "schema": "afterimage-controlled-revisions-review/1",
  "protocol_sha256": "2de64d5b32146eaaf02aa3ae75850e86c18821c300b05215785d3ef535c50be4",
  "commitments_sha256": "dbc7e96f3e3f3f54b8415cd0b4aa95bc350bbea14b295db84a883728984f54fc",
  "reviewer": "Agent, not independent human. No synthetic preference scores.",
  "verdict": "Broad continuity demonstrated on this shot; strict selective preservation remains partial.",
  "samples_per_revision": [
    83,
    92,
    101,
    110,
    119,
    125,
    134,
    143,
    152,
    155,
    166,
    171,
    174
  ],
  "additional_diagnostic_samples": [
    155,
    158,
    161,
    164,
    166,
    168,
    171,
    174
  ],
  "additional_diagnostic_reason": "Inspect the late amber appearance change noticed in the prespecified samples; this did not change inputs, outputs or acceptance definitions.",
  "findings": [
    {
      "question": "Requested transformation",
      "ice": "Frozen blue world visibly realized.",
      "amber": "Warm amber world visibly realized while ice remains. Late amber sky differs strongly from the fixed reference."
    },
    {
      "question": "Recognizable character / swept hair",
      "ice": "Closely follows the supplied identity at inspected anchors and broad identity remains between them. Fine face/hand/body contours differ at the unguided jump.",
      "amber": "Broad identity and swept hair remain. Fine contour differences remain; no exact identity preservation pass is claimed."
    },
    {
      "question": "Performance / camera / timing",
      "ice": "Fall, face-down recovery and jump broadly correspond at sampled source times.",
      "amber": "Same broad action order and corresponding poses remain in samples. Precise all-frame pose, motion and camera equivalence unmeasured."
    },
    {
      "question": "Released prop",
      "ice": "Small prop remains visible in corresponding sampled ground region; exact shape and trajectory unverified.",
      "amber": "Small prop remains visible in corresponding sampled ground region; exact shape and trajectory unverified."
    },
    {
      "question": "Temporal look continuity",
      "ice": "No large extra look change identified in declared samples; flicker-free motion is not certified.",
      "amber": "Between source155 and158, shortly after the final guide, sky and illumination become strongly orange. Extra diagnostic strip documents this; appearance continuity remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "question": "Media integrity",
      "ice": "All92frames decode at24fps,3.833333seconds,1920x1080.",
      "amber": "All92frames decode at24fps,3.833333seconds,1920x1080."
    }
  ],
  "claim_supported": "Five timed images plus a fixed brief can carry a recognizable performed character through two sequential model edits on this development shot, with recorded residual changes. Original anchors are supplied again; no model-memory claim.",
  "claims_not_supported": [
    "Every protected feature is preserved",
    "The model internally remembers the author",
    "Keyframes alone caused improvement over the earlier different prompt",
    "Afterimage outperforms Runway or a skilled compositor",
    "Reduced artist labor, physical relighting accuracy, untouched-case reliability or production readiness"
  ],
  "comparison": "Agent-built conventional all-frame source restoration plus fixed grading. Not equal-information or a timed skilled-artist benchmark.",
  "nuisance_variables": [
    "Stage1 video input1280x720; stage2 raw input1920x1080.",
    "Stage2 inherits stage1 synthesis and compression.",
    "Native source is a640x360 preview derivative.",
    "Model internal preprocessing/weights uncontrolled; seed promises similar not identical requests."
  ],
  "cost": {
    "accepted_generation_tasks": 2,
    "validation_rejections": 2,
    "validation_charge": 0,
    "stage1": 84,
    "stage2": 84,
    "total": 168,
    "balance_after": 248
  },
  "next_evidence": "Untouched shots with the same explicit commitments and independent review, with a competent conventional comparison. No further generation authorized or performed by this script."
}